Tax-benefit microsimulation

PolicyEngine microsimulation

Checked rule by rule, one external costing benchmark, and the limits.

Headline numbers

Household maths is exact; population costings are survey-weighted estimates with no interval.

1p on the UK basic rate, 2026 −5.1% vs HMRC ready reckoner Benchmark, not validation
Executable check, 2026 ±5% band around £6.55bn Skipped without microdata
Evidence by dimension: the registry’s categorical judgement, and what would change it
DimensionLevelWhat would change it
Implementation fidelitystrongMeasured per-country statutory test coverage
Predictive validationnot applicableNone; not applicable by construction
Identificationnot applicableNone
Policy counterfactualsmoderateA US reform benchmarked to an independent costing
UncertaintyweakBootstrap ranges on population aggregates
Vintage reproducibilitymoderateAggregates reproducible without gated microdata

The two checks

Rule arithmetic by hand, and one costing against HMRC.

1

Checked rule by rule

No forecast error to report: the model applies published rules.

About this stepnotes

Exact rule arithmetic

Check
the worked £50,000 case, by pencil
Where
the Use it tab
Verifies
the implemented rules
Does not verify
that every area is covered by a test

A hand check verifies the implemented rules, not that every area of legislation is covered by a test.

2

The one external comparison

A survey-weighted costing against HMRC’s post-behavioural ready reckoner.

About this step6 points

1p on the basic rate

Ours, 2026
£6.55bn, static
HMRC, 2026–27
£6.9bn, post-behavioural
Ours vs HMRC, 2028–29
£7.01bn vs £8.2bn (−14.5%)
Ours, 2030
£7.48bn, no counterpart
Executable check
2026 within ±5%, skipped without microdata
  • Population costings are survey-weighted estimates; the pipeline produces no interval (limits).
  • HMRC’s June 2025 ready reckoner is post-behavioural on administrative SPI data. Ours is static and survey-based, so this is a benchmark, not a validation.
  • A static costing below a post-behavioural one runs against intuition. The paper’s leading explanation is the data basis: administrative data capture the top of the income distribution more completely than a survey. Nothing yet decomposes the gap.
  • The reckoner stops at 2028–29, so the 2030 figure has no counterpart.
  • Every figure comes from hosted runs under policyengine 6.11.1; job ids are in papers/pe-microsim/figures/basic_rate_costing.json. Under policyengine 4.x they were £6.46bn and £7.38bn.
  • The executable check is test_population_impact_uk_real_basic_rate in integration/tests/test_population.py.

Limits

What the model leaves out, and the data and versions it runs on.

Known limits of the tax-benefit microsimulation
LimitDetail
Static, no general equilibrium Prices, wages and output do not move; behavioural responses are optional and post-hoc.
UK data vintage enhanced_frs_2023_24; upstream's FRS 2024-25 vintage is not adopted here.
Survey-based aggregates Population estimates carry sampling, imputation and ageing error, and no interval is computed for them. HMRC's costings use administrative Survey of Personal Incomes data and embed taxable-income elasticities, so a few hundred million of difference on a broad-based rate change is expected.
Gated UK microdata Population runs need a HUGGING_FACE_TOKEN with access. Household calculations are unaffected.
Statute-vintage divergence with OLG This package tracks the latest release; the OLG member is pinned to policyengine-uk==2.88.0, so baseline statute can disagree — a declared inconsistency.
Related papersMacro models this one feeds

Papers on the macro models this one feeds: OBR, OLG.