Two-asset HANK
US HANK
The parameters it solves against the paper, what is imposed, and the limits.
Partial replication, not a forecast-accuracy claim
Solved parameters against the paper’s Table B.III; the headline targets are inputs, not results.
| Check | Against | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solved steady-state parameters | Auclert et al. (2021) Table B.III, gate under 5e−4, largest gap 4.2e−4; vphi after × μw² | 6 of 7 direct, 1 after conversion | pass |
| Goods-market clearing (untargeted) | Walras’ law: should be zero | 3.3e−08 | pass |
| Impulse-response signs | Theory, three shock kinds, both directions; spending impact multiplier in (0, 1) | all gated by tests | pass |
| Impulse-response magnitudes | The one magnitude the paper states: impact consumption after a −5pp monetary shock, ρ 0.6 (Fig. 7a), 1.46%; shock units inferred. Every other response is regression-pinned only | 1.485%, within about 2% | partial |
| First-order accuracy | The model’s own nonlinear solve; the intercept easing shock within 4%, spending 1% of GDP is not | 0.175 vs 0.251 / 0.125 | partial |
| Spending multiplier (ρ 0.8) | No published benchmark; 0.376 on impact in the opt-in 0.20-MPC calibration | 0.175 impact, −0.015 over 20q | weak |
| Hand-to-mouth share | About one third of US households (Kaplan, Violante and Weidner 2014) | 0.537, of which 0.518 wealthy | fail |
| Quarterly MPC out of a rebate | 0.15–0.25 in US rebate studies; rebates of $500 / $1,000 / $1,500 per household, refined grid | 0.104 / 0.091 / 0.083 | fail |
Evidence by dimension
| Dimension | Level | What would change it |
|---|---|---|
| Implementation fidelity | strong | Replication gates across all shocks and variants |
| Predictive validation | not applicable | None: not a forecaster |
| Identification | not applicable | None: calibrated, not an identified VAR |
| Policy counterfactuals | weak | A published HANK multiplier to check against |
| Uncertainty | weak | Sensitivity to price, wage and MPC calibration |
| Vintage reproducibility | strong | None while calibration stays frozen |
About this replicationIndependent build, not endorsed
An independent replication of a published academic model, built on the authors' own sequence-jacobian toolkit, not produced or endorsed by them. Results are model counterfactuals, not official estimates or forecasts.
What it solves, and what is imposed
The parameters it solves for
The ground truth is the published paper, not data.
| parameter | paper | ours | |diff| |
|---|---|---|---|
| betadiscount factor, solved numerically | 0.976 | 0.9762739 | 2.7e-04 |
| chi1portfolio adjustment cost scale, solved numerically | 6.416 | 6.41642 | 4.2e-04 |
| ZTFP, solved analytically | 0.468 | 0.4677898 | 2.1e-04 |
| alphacapital share, solved analytically | 0.33 | 0.3299492 | 5.1e-05 |
| mu_pprice markup, solved analytically | 1.015 | 1.015228 | 2.3e-04 |
| taulabour tax rate, solved analytically | 0.356 | 0.3560606 | 6.1e-05 |
| vphiwage Phillips curve disutility scale, after × μw² | 2.073 | 2.073306 | 3.1e-04 |
Six of seven agree to the last published digit directly; vphi solves to 1.7135 and matches after multiplying by μw² = 1.21, because Table B.III follows the working paper's wage-markup convention and this implementation the published appendix's (us-hank-model #15).
Calibration inputs, held fixed through the solve, so their deviations are identities:
Constants equalling themselves: Output Y 1, Capital K 10, Real rate r 0.0125, Government spending G 0.2, Government debt Bg 2.8.
Solver targets: Total wealth A+B 14 hit to 2.7e-13, Liquid assets B 1.04 hit to 9.5e-14 — tolerances, not accuracies.
Market clearing: goods 3.3e-08 untargeted (Walras’ law), assets 3.1e-13 is the solver’s own target.
Source: US HANK replication
Source details
Source: papers/us-hank/figures/replication.json.
How each parameter is solvedThe vphi convention, and when it was solved
- β 0.9762739 against 0.976, and χ1 6.4164196 against 6.416. χ1 is solved numerically from a 6.5 starting guess, the strongest single check.
- Z, α, μp and τ are solved analytically.
- The seventh,
vphi, solves to 1.7135 against a published 2.073: a convention, not an error. - This implementation follows the published Econometrica appendix, which divides the after-tax wage by μw. The NBER working paper multiplies by μw instead, giving exactly μw² = 1.21 times ours, 2.0733.
- Both versions print 2.073, so Table B.III follows the working paper. The two values describe the same steady state.
- The model repo now asserts the conversion (us-hank-model #15).
- Solved 2026-07-29 at production grids (nB=50, nA=70, nK=50) and re-solved independently 2026-08-13. The seven parameters and the goods-market residual are the same in the model’s
docs/VALIDATION.mdat the pinned commit 58353e5f.
What is gated, and what is not
Imposed inputs carry no information; signs, timing and one published magnitude are gated, other magnitudes are only regression-pinned.
The one published magnitudeFig. 7a: units, source and the nonlinear check
- One published magnitude is reproduced within about 2%: impact consumption after a −5pp Taylor-rule shock with quarterly persistence 0.6 (Fig. 7a of Auclert et al. 2021).
- Linear solution: 1.485% against the paper’s 1.46% (+1.7%). Nonlinear: 1.388% against 1.36% (+2.1%) (
tests/test_published_magnitude.py). - Units are inferred: the paper does not state them. Annualised percentage points (−1.25pp per quarter) fits; the quarterly reading gives 5.94%.
- The paper’s numbers are read from the working-paper text (NBER w26123, Fig. 8a there); the Econometrica text was not checked for them.
- Other magnitudes are not gated: output, investment, inflation and the spending and productivity responses are sign-checked and regression-pinned only.
Where this sits among other open HANK implementations: the landscape report.
More detailnotes
Status of each result
- Imposed
- Y, K, r, G, Bg — identities
- Solver-reached
- total wealth, liquid assets — tolerances
- Asset clearing
- about 3e−13, the solver’s own target
- IRF signs, timing
- gated
- Impact consumption, Fig. 7a shock
- gated within 3% of the paper
- Other IRF magnitudes
- regression-pinned on this implementation; no published response to match