Bank of England structural VAR
BoE SVAR
How the replication and the forecasts score, and where it departs from the Bank’s model.
GDP variance share consistent with the paper; no forecast skill
Two kinds of check: replication against the published paper, and forecasts scored against outturns.
| Check | Against | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Global shocks’ share of UK GDP variance | Brignone and Piffer (2025): ~40%, 4 quarters | 38.7% (68% band 24.0–53.1) | pass |
| Global shocks’ share of UK CPI variance | Paper: ~50%, 4 quarters | 41.5% (25.6–56.3), 8.5pp short | partial |
| Domestic shares and their ranking | Paper: ~40% for both; monetary policy the largest | 38.6% / 36.8%; monetary policy 8.9% of CPI variance, third of three | partial |
| Exact identities | Zero and sign restrictions, revision adding-up; gated in CI; software, not economics | max error 3.64e-12 | by construction |
| One frozen forecast | ONS outturns 2024Q3–2026Q1, from the 2024Q2 edge; one origin | RMSE 0.32pp GDP and CPI; 14 of 14 in the 68% band (about 9.5 expected) | partial |
| Point-forecast accuracy | Random walk with drift; 50 origins, 8 variables × 8 horizons | 0 of 64 survive adjustment (smallest q 0.39) | fail |
| Band coverage | Nominal 68% and 90%; 50 origins; mean of 8 variables, CPI on the published year-on-year basis | 68% band 70% → 57%; UK CPI 90% band 78% → 54% | weak |
| Monetary policy shock size | Bank of England (1999): 0.2–0.35% of GDP for a 1pp rise | about 1.6% of GDP per 100bp at h = 8 (pre-refresh run, not recounted) | fail |
Evidence by dimension
| Dimension | Level | What would change it |
|---|---|---|
| Implementation fidelity | strong | All exact invariants hard-gated for every spec |
| Predictive validation | weak | Density scores and rolling coverage, post-Covid re-run |
| Identification | moderate | Results shown across lag, prior and proxy grids |
| Policy counterfactuals | not applicable | Keeps refusing reform scoring |
| Uncertainty | moderate | Rolling coverage and proper predictive scores |
| Vintage reproducibility | moderate | Frozen manifests; real-time and revised vintages |
About this replicationIndependent; not a Bank of England product
An independent replication built from Bank of England Macro Technical Paper No. 3 and public data. It is not produced, maintained or endorsed by the Bank of England; do not present its results as Bank of England estimates.
The four tests
Data and sampleData through 2026Q2, sample from 1992Q1
Every figure here uses data through 2026Q2, except test 2 (frozen origin, scored through 2026Q1), and the estimation sample 1992Q1–2025Q1 (boe-var-model #24); earlier figures are at commit 845e2a4.
Where this departs from the Bank’s model
| Limit | Detail |
|---|---|
| Frozen data edge | Estimation to 2025Q1, conditioning to 2026Q2 — the extended sample, not the paper's 1992Q1–2023Q2 window. Results shift with revisions. |
| Proxied world aggregates | The Bank's UK-trade-weighted world GDP and CPI are unpublished, so they are rebuilt as chain-weighted US + euro-area + Japan + China with time-varying UK trade weights. |
| One ranking does not replicate |
|
| Assumed lag length; loose pandemic prior | p = 4 is assumed, not selected; the pandemic is handled by six exogenous Covid dummies with a loose prior, which is the Cascaldi-Garcia (2022) pandemic prior at its uninformative default. |
| The posterior is mildly explosive |
|
| No inflation anchor |
|
| No after-the-fact fix brings the 90% band to 90% |
|
| Rate-shock response above the Bank of England’s estimate |
|
| Sign-restriction critiques apply | Pointwise medians mix structural models (Fry–Pagan); the Haar prior over rotations is informative about impulse responses (Baumeister–Hamilton). These hit the Bank's own outputs identically. |
Every deviation is listed in the repository's docs/methodology.md.